chuckro: (Default)
chuckro ([personal profile] chuckro) wrote2007-04-24 11:35 am

Story Stretching

I'm into rambling this week, aren't I?



My father was the first person I noticed to lament this problem with comic books: That what was once enough plot for a single issue has slowly been stretched into two-parters, then 4-issue miniseries, then six- or eight-issue miniseries. The 8-issue Uncle Sam and the Freedom Fighters miniseries that recently came out, for instance, was basically the origin of the new Freedom Fighters. Okay, fine. But eight issues? I feel like there were 6-page backup stories with the secret origin of the Justice League that had just as much plot and characterization, just fewer redundancies and splash panels. And this is a theme of the superhero books--1-issue stories become 4-issue arcs; and you can miss three issues of a six-issue mini and effectively miss nothing.

Am I just being crotchety here?

I'm currently working on an idea for a three-and-a-half session low-level D&D game, based on a single storyline with hopefully an emphasis on character interaction. But I want to make sure it's worth the time that goes into it. Normally, when I'm running a campaign, I try to make sure that every session has it's own beginning, middle and end to the story, and that it advances the ongoing plot and as many subplots as can fit. And I'll admit, pacing can be a bitch. But that's no excuse for taking one game's worth of story and padding it out to an arc by filling it full of combat scenes.

Which is just another problem of my recent Skype D&D arc.

[identity profile] skalja.livejournal.com 2007-04-24 06:08 pm (UTC)(link)
Yeah, I'm a fan of decompression and even I've had my fill of the stuff (although I still read Bendis, probably because he makes the character beats worth the pacing). Four to six issues is good, really - I can sort of see why publishers would prefer a six issue mini if they can swing it, because the trade will look meatier on the shelf, but as far as ongoing series go, two four-issue arcs make a perfectly solid collection!

I suspect you lasted about five issues longer into Justice League than I did. Have I actually missed anything? Is the League actually formed yet?

[identity profile] chuckro.livejournal.com 2007-04-24 06:32 pm (UTC)(link)
The latest incarnation? I think it's officially formed. Frankly, they spent five issues on a Red Tornado story that should have been either one issue by itself, or a subplot while other things were going on. No other things were going on.

[identity profile] skalja.livejournal.com 2007-04-24 06:33 pm (UTC)(link)
*facepalm*

I hear that Roy is now Red Arrow, as well? Sigh.

[identity profile] jethrien.livejournal.com 2007-04-24 09:31 pm (UTC)(link)
Oh, yeah. I totally forgot that they were trying to reform the Justice League, what with all the android-angst.

Did they actually make the official call on whether to include Batman, or not? Are we supposed to still be in suspense about that one?